Going For It

8.1.09 Red Rocks (G.Lucas)

8.1.09 Red Rocks (G.Lucas)

In Phish’s continuing dominance of the Red Rocks stage, they launched a Saturday night show that carried a heavyweight ninety minute first set as well as another second set strewn with risk taking and creativity.  Since coming to Colorado, it seems that the band is making a point to take all of their jams to unique places, a virtual antithesis of June’s contained and directed playing.  Clearly far more musically comfortable together only a month later, Phish seems like they have rekindled their determination and desire of the mid-Nineties, but with all of the musical acumen they have accumulated over the years, resulting in some of the most magnificent music from the band in ages.  2009 is great time to be a Phish fan, and last night delivered several more reasons why.

8.1.09 (G.Lucas)

8.1.09 (G.Lucas)

While “AC/DC Bag” opened the show, the moment of truth that so many have awaited came next.  Taking everyone by surprise, and a minute to register, Phish was stepping up to play “The Curtain (With)” for the first time since they finishing their “career” by horribly botching one of their most sacred compositions at Coventry.  We all wondered when the band would confront the piece that left us with the most bittersweet ending possible five years ago.  And last night was the night.  With supreme confidence, the band nailed “The Curtain” and when they entered “With” the mood became reverent.  As a silence drew over the crowd, the band delicately painted the initial, would-be “Rift,” melody through the summer night like a sunset reverie.  Blissfully flowing through the song’s ethereal textures and sublime improvisation, the band played with breathtaking majesty and emotion as a sense of redemption filled the the air.  By far the most significant highlight of the night, all was right in the Phish world again; the past was fully behind us and only the sense of possibility lies ahead.

8.1.09 (G.Lucas)

8.1.09 (G.Lucas)

The first set fireworks continued with the bust out of “Mound” for the first time since their first comeback show at MSG in 2002- and before that, 1996.  Played with such precision, and having been absent from setlists for so long, it virtually sounded like we were hearing a new song.  Reminded of the song’s quirky rhythms and melodies, it was like visiting an old friend after almost forgetting they existed.  The most standout first set of Red Rocks continued with a triumphant “Jibboo,” that after “The Curtain (With),” felt like a bursting celebration of Phish’s return to to happiness.  Trey stood out, taking the jam into a quiet beginning before bringing it to a soaring peak in the waning hours of a gorgeous summer day.

7.31.09 (A.King)

7.31.09 (B. Carlson)

It was at this point that Phishy antics reentered the scene for one of the first times this go-round.  Trey announced that this would be the “hand signal” portion of the show, and proceeded to make silly gestures to communicate what the next song would be for the rest of the set. A sure fire sign that the band’s heart is back and in the right place, Trey created a mock pig nose, pretended to punch Mike and Page in the eye, continually stretched an elongated tube to allow Fishman to catch on, mushed a dog sled, and entered a pseudo-antelope trot throughout the rest of the set without talking to his bandmates at all.  Like a mini game show before each song, fans had a chance to guess Trey’s signal before the band busted the next song, bringing the element of fun firmly back to their live show.  And their enthusiasm was infectious, as the Saturday night crowd became giddy with the band’s energy.

The “Tube” was the loosest yet, as Gordon laid down some heavy bass lines to compliment Page’s clav work and Trey’s fiery licks.  Maintaining a serious pace to the funk, the band opened up the song a bit more, but the set’s improvisational highlight certainly came in a scorching set ending “Antelope.” Bringing back memories of Red Rocks “Antelopes” of the ’93 and ’94, the band got creative with the song for the first time in eons.  Taking a left turn out of the song’s aggressive grooves into psychedelic debauchery, the band took the jam into maniacal, abstract darkness before crashing back to earth.

8.1.09 (G.Lucas)

8.1.09 (G.Lucas)

Following the first setbreak of the weekend that actually felt like summer, the band stepped out for their sixth set of the run and continued to take daring musical risks.  The anthemic Saturday night set began with the one-two punch of “Rock and Roll > Disease,” both jams entering completely original territory, though not nearly as flowing as Friday night’s spectacle.  After an extended high-energy shred session through the song’s straight ahead rock, thing got more interesting as the music slowed down, moving into some exploratory improv.  Featuring some prominent bass work by Mike and collective stops and starts by band members, Phish was at it again, exercising creativity over safety, putting together a unique, yet somewhat disjointed, jam.  Finally working their way into “Disease” in a less than fluid manner, their classic vehicle took center stage.  Moving into a percussive groove and into some totally original improv, the excursion was both poly-rhythmic and Fishman-centric.  The band wound their way through several innovative segments of non-guitar-led improvisation, and into a completely different vibe than anything we’ve heard so far.  Phish was going for it in what was certainly the most out-there and entertaining jam of the night.

8.1.09 (G.Lucas)

8.1.09 (G.Lucas)

The rest of the show, though well-played throughout, was fairly straight forward.  When they segued into “Free,” I thought for sure that the band would let loose within the confines of those massive rocks, but the song was- again- wrapped up quickly, used only as a landing point for “Disease.”  The long-awaited return of “Esther” finally came for the first time since 2000; another reminder of an amazing Phish song we have long forgot about, and continuing the trend of accessing the full range of their catalog.  “Dirt” filled in the second-set ballad slot before the band closed with a gorgeous “Hood” that connected with the summer evening in regal fashion.  Taking the old-school jam on a meticulous path to a show-ending peak, “Hood” left every one feeling good after a very upbeat set.  And the “First Tube” encore would put an exclamation point on the night.

While the jams might not have been as cohesive last night as Friday, nobody can deny that Phish showcased their renewed spirit of discovery once again.  With the band taking copious musical risks, each set won’t turn out to be a masterpiece, but it’s all about the ride- and right now, Phish is a pretty wild ride with mysteries lurking around every corner.  And what more can we ask for from our psychedelic juggernauts but to go for the jugular and see what happens.  It’s inspiring to see them so ready and willing to put their ideas out there for testing.  The unknown adventure is what this is all about, and right now, each set is exactly that.  Stay tuned for Sunday’s conclusion- more intrigue awaits.

I: AC/DC Bag, The Curtain With, Mound, Gotta Jibboo, Guyute, Punch You In the Eye, Tube, Alaska, Run Like an Antelope
II: Rock and Roll > Down with Disease > Free, Esther, Dirt, Harry Hood
E: Sleeping Monkey, First Tube


8.1.09 Red Rocks (Photo: Graham Lucas)

Tags: ,

278 Responses to “Going For It”

  1. Robear Says:

    Col, I gotcha covered at Indio! Re: no samples

  2. albert walker Says:

    a little people working, good treats, but no Shakedown

  3. BrandonKayda Says:

    Camden and Deer Creek were the best 1st leg IMO.

    Brooklyn 2004-6-17 was a good show, so was SPAC

    So is it safe to say tonight will be the best?

  4. Mitch Says:

    I think you’re being a little harsh. Everyone has their own opinion but dude, c’mon. You cant say they sucked leg 1. Thats just ridiculous in MY OPINION.

  5. ColonelJoy Says:

    Has there been a shakedown anywhere this summer?

  6. ColonelJoy Says:


    I thought some of what pass in jamming in leg 1, and Trey’s horrible tone were quite sucky. Harsh, but that is how I feel, but leg 1 is over, thank god.

  7. EL Duderino Says:

    I guess the Red Rocks parking lots are not conducive to a shakedown. All the different tiers and all. Shoreline and Gorge are great ones for those kinds of things. ’96 Rocks didn’t really have a Shakedown either

  8. notkuroda Says:

    with the summer festival season kicking, it’s probably not as profitible to sell wares on phish tour.

  9. ColonelJoy Says:


    Good point about Wook-Econ

  10. msbjivein Says:

    One Word Describes my Red Rocks experience so far…………….

  11. ColonelJoy Says:

    You’re a lucky, lucky bastard, MSBJ

  12. MP Says:

    Regarding Leg 1 vs Leg 2. I dont think that break was an accident The band must have known they would benefit from some alone time to learn from the mistakes of leg 1. RR sounds great. Phish is love.

  13. Robear Says:

    I’m so glad this scene is back together. The band gets my thanks for that. Incredible feelings to be had, incredible connections with people happen nightly. Thanks again. The three groups at the WW Booth have had great exposure, great times, and crucial fundraising.

  14. DaNcInG fOoL Says:

    prediction: tonight is only gonna get better woooooooo 30 minute jam

  15. msbjivein Says:

    What’s left for Day 4????????
    I’ve come up w/ some realistic songs that might/should appear tonight.
    Let Me Lie
    IT’S ICE
    46 DAYS
    Llama(I’ve seen Llamas everyday in the park on my way to the Venue)
    CITIES……………………………….What did I miss?????

  16. DaNcInG fOoL Says:

    @colonel “On the whole, minus a few, few highlights, Leg 1 sucked! Only the worst moments of 2.0 can compete with it’s suckitude. Honestly, I was being gentle during Leg 1 out of respect for this forum, and I didn’t care to spew on everyone. I’m glad RR has reminded everyone here what this band is all about.”

    exactly my thoughts… aside from maybe RR1’s weekapaug where trey’s whaling is out of control, RR has been fucking amazing

  17. guyforget Says:

    i think those llamas are deer.

  18. Mr. Completely Says:

    honestly it sounds a little like they spent the break reading this forum and absorbing the constructive criticism found here, taking it into the practice room and polishing it up for 2nd leg

    Curtain With is the most meaningful breakout because of coventry – but Esther – WOW – and beautifully played taboot. The Vegas ’00 one was fucked up, remember – not in a coventry-esque heartbreaking way, but still, Trey completely borked the lyrics at the end. So that’s 2 big rarities redeemed, plus Mound!

    We had the hoostream running, which despite the flaws and cutoffs was an amazing experience. Esther is my wife’s favorite rarity, it made her very happy to hear it.

    The night before was a nearly perfect improvisational journey, no surprise this one had a different emphasis.

    Still another epic win for the home team.

  19. ColonelJoy Says:

    Oh yeah, forgot about Reba….that will be sick…plenty left in the tank

    3 best shows of the year were just played, and still many sick jams remain.

    Has there ever been a better musical experience than Phish?

  20. msbjivein Says:

    Guy, I know what fucking deer look like and those are not deer. They’re Def Llamas dude. Taboot Taboot

  21. DaNcInG fOoL Says:

    birds of a feather> undermind

  22. voopa Says:

    Sand> Scents

  23. DaNcInG fOoL Says:

    i’ve never been so excited to hear a YEM…. esther was great but it proabbly would have been better suited in the first set but oh well

    tons of possibilities for tonight

  24. msbjivein Says:

    Slide and the silicone embrace you as you fall

  25. msbjivein Says:

    I love 1st set Antelope closers!!!!!!!!!!!
    YEM 1st set closer tonight….!!!!!

Leave a Reply