The Return of New Year’s Eve

"New Year's Eve" (Photo: Wendy Rogell)

New Year’s Eve; out with the old and in with the new. As long as anyone could remember, Phish and December 31 went together like peanut butter and jelly. Whether in the cold of Worcester, Boston, and New York, or the warmth of Big Cypress and Miami, Phish and New Year’s Eve were one in the same. On a holiday where the entire point is to have a blast celebrating the year that was, Phish’s New Year’s Eve shows became rites of passage, culminating with 1999’s sacred millennial odyssey in The Everglades. But after this experience of a lifetime, Phish appeared only twice on New Year’s Eve over the next ten years. We hadn’t flipped the calendar with them since 2003 in this very same building on Biscayne Bay, thus New Year’s Eve ’09 took on a renewed feeling of excitement that had been gone for more than half a decade.

12.31.09 (W.Rogell)

Without the grind of their night-long parties of yesteryear, Phish came to bat on the 31st locked and loaded, building off, arguably, their two finest shows of the year. Just as each of the previous nights had a distinct theme, New Year’s Eve was colored by feel-good Phish from beginning to end, ringing in 2010 with songs of joy and upbeat jamming; everything we’ve come to expect from the band in their three-set, year-end parties. And before we knew it, we were off on a musical crash course with a brand new decade.

The ride got started with the energetic one-two punch of “AC/DC Bag” and “46 Days,” but got kicked into high gear by the fourth-song “Bathtub Gin.” A jubilant vibe painted the entire jam which moved from glue-tight structured territory into a heavier dose of groove; the latter segment pushed forward by none other than Michael Gordon, the unquestionable player of the weekend. His driving bass patterns attracted Fish, and, on the spot, they reinvented the pocket of the jam, and Trey and Page followed their lead. A fiery segment of holiday improv resulted from this group conversation, with all members completely in tune. “Gin” became the first taste of the band’s inspiring New Year’s themed playing, characterized by densely packed catharsis.

12.31.09 (Photo: Wendy Rogell)

The chunkier part of the set continued with full-speed runs through “Punch” and “Moma,” keeping the energy high and people moving to the beat. Breaking for a composition, Phish played only the second “Guyute” since summer, and its triumphant nature fit congruently on this night. But the most intriguing first-set sequence came next. Playing through their Billy Breathes segment, “Swept Away > Steep,” at the point where they used to scream, and more recently, just drop into a new song, the band fluidly drifted into a mellow, Beatles-esque psychedelia, led hand in hand by Trey and Page. If this wasn’t composed ahead of time, I’d be surprised, as Page and Trey immediately initiated the same melodic theme. One way or the other, Phish stumbled upon something gorgeous in this piece, and its inward journey served as a reflective interlude for the end of the year.

12.31.09 (W.Rogell)

As this jam settled, Phish broke into the opening of “Demand” for the first time since Ames, Iowa during November ’96, thus trumping “Tela” for the “biggest” bust-out of the weekend. Played like they’d kept it in rotation all along, Phish nailed the two minute piece and hopped right into “Seven Below.” A song that birthed two standout jams of fall stayed closer to its structure this time around, but still provided inspired improv with Fishman maintaining a strapping beat behind a melodic canvas. When listening to Mike on this piece, one will hear some of his most intriguing play of an outlandish weekend, offering up lines most musicians wouldn’t even conceive. Collectively driving this piece to the top, the band played as a four-headed monster flowing with effortless abandon, once again packing a whole lot of action into a very short time. Closing the first set with a rollicking “Julius,” Phish got off to a phenomenal start on their return to a night they once owned.

12.31.09 (W.Rogell)

A particularly short set break had the lights off way before anyone expected, and one of the weekend’s strongest sets kicked off with the 2009 anthem “Rock and Roll.” Sewing this stanza thematically together with a dense, uptempo musical thread, Phish began by tearing the opener into oblivion. As the music entered a potentially deeper plane, Trey elected to keep the set bumpin’ with energy, segueing quickly into “Piper.” Phish filled the subsequent ten minutes with over the top, compact improv at a dizzying pace. As if trying to summarize all the places the jam has reached during its epic year, the band threw down a concentrated, complex gauntlet that moved a mile a minute. Playing with ridiculous cohesion, the band straight annihilated the final “Piper” in a year that featured many magnificent journeys from the song. Combining two of 2009’s defining pieces, the band opened the second set like a musical incarnation of Usain Bolt.

The blissful vibe continued as the band morphed from an ambient landing into “Simple.” A song played only four times in 2009, none were more symbolic than this version on New Year’s Eve. Things had returned to an Edenic state in the Phish universe, and on the cusp of 2010, the lyrics never meant more to everyone, because once again, “…we’ve got a band.” Moving from a melodic jam into a spacier outro, Mike and Trey chased each others’ phrases into nothingness as the band faded into “Theme.” Keeping the fun, yet emotional, night moving, the band infused the song with a soaring energy and musicianship that brought the opening, non-stop segment of the set to a close.

12.31.09 (Photo: Wendy Rogell)

Giving a nod to their unforgettable “Exile” set from Halloween, the band used the album’s emotional peak, “Shine a Light,” as mid-set interlude. Another lyrically appropriate song for a celebration of all that is to come for the Phish community, this version came perfectly placed in an increasingly impressive set. And then came the expedition of the night in a multi-faceted, bass-led safari through “Ghost.” Trey laid way back as the jam began, allowing Mike to take center stage with his bouncing, envelope-filtered leads. Like a space-general, Gordon thumped out futuristic patterns as his band fell in behind him. The pocket grew Grand Canyon-deep, as Mike’s basscrobatics bounced brains like basketballs around D Wade’s building. Crafting one of the weekends most compelling pieces, the band continued their unified jamming that underlined the entire evening.

12.31.09 (Photo: Wendy Rogell)

As “Ghost” built into an dark, abstract realm, Mike took his effects off, allowing Trey to take the lead for the second half of the jam. Flowing with inspired melodies, Trey awed the arena with his path to the mountaintop, where the band slid into a post-peak series of grooves that became increasingly delicate and ambient. Trey wove a stunning “Auld Lang Syne” tease amidst this emotive musical tapestry before Phish swam into a drone soundscape. Just as everyone thought the band would ooze the set to a close, Mike brought us into the dentist chair with “NO2.” Maintaining their shimmering backdrop throughout his narration, the band buzzed into silence before dropping an explosive “Suzie” to close one of the superior sets of the run.

"Midnight" (W.Rogell)

After another abbreviated setbreak, everyone knew what songs the band had left to play. Miami’s final set would inevitably include “Disease,” “Fluffhead,” and “You Enjoy Myself,” but how it would go down would be the story of the final frame. Launching into “Party Time” with about six minutes until midnight, the band funked into the New Year, showering everyone with Phish’s first “Auld Lang Syne” since ’03. An always-emotional moment – one where I always feel so thankful for being in the right place at the right time – this one felt extra sweet after five years of differing midnight festivities.

Everyone knew that “Disease” stood in the on deck circle, but this year, this set wasn’t about surprise – at least not yet. Featuring another theme song of ’09 in the slot where its triumphant jam was born sixteen years earlier, this moment was about simply being there again; seeing those big balloons bounce in front of our favorite band as we spun into a new decade to the soundtrack of our lives. After such a smoking second set, this one brought high octane playing, all in the name of fun. Staying firmly within the box throughout the final frame, the point wasn’t exploration, but explosive celebration, and Phish certainly accomplished their goal to the delight of all.

"Disease" (W.Rogell)

"Auld Lang Syne" (W.Rogell)

Instead of providing musical twists and turns in their final set, the band chose to mess with our minds with a prank that left everyone disputing what the hell actually had happened long after the show ended. Having laid the groundwork with all of the vacuum shenanigans over the 28th and 30th, and having foreshadowed the gag with the 30th’s cover, “Dixie Cannonball,” the band had the audience right where they wanted them. After ending “Disease,” they brought a life size disco ball to the center of the stage, and Fishman crawled inside. Bringing out a cannon and illuminating a net above the soundboard, Phish created the preposterous illusion that they were about to launch Fishman into the rafters of the arena – and for a split second, it all seemed totally reasonable. Trey got behind the drum set and gave a dramatic roll as the cannon fired loudly. Material hung from the roof as if Fishman shot right through, as a faux helicopter’s search light descended over the crowd with full-on sound effects. But neither Fishman, nor the disco cannonball, was anywhere to be seen.

12.31.09 (W.Rogell)

Much like the previous night, the band called for someone from the audience to replace Fishman – this time on drums. Trey called someone out from the stands to the left side of the stage side, and a dark-haired girl made her way to the drum set. After gushing over Trey in a comic act, when asked her favorite Phish tune, she replied “Fluffhead,” to the roaring approval of the crowd. Trey then announced that the band would play “Fluffhead” with Sarah on drums. As she awkwardly starting the song, Trey looked over and seemed to help Sarah along, and soon she caught the groove and the band launched into the song much to everyone’s shock. What the fuck was going on?! And from the end of “Disease,” that is exactly what Phish wanted us to wonder – and they pulled it of with genius. In an incognito switcheroo, a wigged and costumed Fishman slid onto the drums with hardly anyone noticing, leaving everybody with a different theory as to what happened and how. After the show ended, a friend came up to me and asked, “So, did Sarah play the rest of the set with them?” ‘Nuff said!

12.31.09 (Photo: Wendy Rogell)

Featuring solid versions of “Fluffhead,” “Coil,” and “You Enjoy Myself,” this set, more than anything, brought the spectacle back to New Year’s Eve, while continuing the uplifting theme to the evening. And it worked out quite well. Poignantly fitting “Joy” into their final set as well, the band reminded everyone what this era is all about – our collective happiness. And after some lyrical, heartfelt thanks from Trey, a “Loving Cup” encore brought us home. Capping 2009 with a set defined by their prankster spirit, Phish hit every angle over their four nights in Miami, reclaiming their undisputed title as the musical pimps of the universe. And what a year it was!  From March 6 in Hampton to December 31 in Miami, and everything in between, 2009 saw the re-evolution of Phish; a force of nature unto themselves. And side by side, the return of our dreams. It all really happened.

Phish 2010, here we come!

I: AC/DC Bag, 46 Days, Water in the Sky, Bathtub Gin, Punch You in the Eye, The Moma Dance, Guyute, Swept Away > Steep, Demand > Seven Below, Lawn Boy, Julius

II.Rock and Roll > Piper > Simple > Theme from the Bottom, Shine A Light, Ghost > NO2, Suzy Greenberg

III: Party Time > Auld Lang Syne > Down With Disease, NYE Prank, Fluffhead, Joy, The Squirming Coil, You Enjoy Myself

E: Blue Moon, Loving Cup

"2010" (Photo: Wendy Rogell)


Jams of the Day: 12.31.09 II

Rock and Roll > Piper


Ghost > NO2


The improvisational meat of New Year’s second set.



12.31.09 American Airlines Arena, Miami, FL < Torrent

12.31.09 American Airlines Arena, Miami, FL < Megaupload

12.31.09 (W.Rogell)

I: AC/DC Bag, 46 Days, Water in the Sky, Bathtub Gin, Punch You in the Eye, The Moma Dance, Guyute, Swept Away > Steep, Demand > Seven Below, Lawn Boy, Julius

II.Rock and Roll > Piper > Simple > Theme from the Bottom, Shine A Light, Ghost > NO2, Suzy Greenberg

III: Party Time > Auld Lang Syne > Down With Disease, NYE Prank, Fluffhead, Joy, The Squirming Coil, You Enjoy Myself

E: Blue Moon*, Loving Cup

*Trey thanks all members of the Phish organization by reading their names off a list “as quickly and lyrically as possible” to the tune of “Blue Moon.”

Source: Sennheiser MD441U > Edirol R4Pro ( Oade preamp mod ) @ 24/88.2 (Taper – padelimike)


Video of the Day: Auld Lang Syne > NYE Prank

Tags: , ,

702 Responses to “The Return of New Year’s Eve”

  1. Marshall Says:

    Thanks Palmer. So she never made it up on stage all. Thanks for pointing me to the video.

  2. kenny powers Says:

    Awesome story Marshall!

  3. KWL Says:

    I think it is safe to say that Miner’s reviews have become ‘crack-like’ 😉

  4. KWL Says:

    sorry I missed out on some great conversation last night. Interestingly, I was actually thinking and writing about many of the same things, and even meditated before I went to bed–talk about being in touch with the collective vibe of the blackboard!

    was day 1 of my new year’s resolution to create time-spaces that enable creativity.

  5. Neemor Says:

    “reclaiming their undisputed title as the musical pimps of the universe.”


    Nice Miner.

  6. Marshall Says:

    Phish has reached that level of playing again where I laugh at those who don’t get it or have never caught a show.

  7. EL Duderino Says:

    @ Marshall

    Fortunately it’s not for everyone. Imagine how hard it would be to see shows if everybody liked Phish as much as us? No Thnaks

  8. jay Says:

    nice Marshal!

  9. HarryHood Says:

    Another great write up Miner! Golf Clap….. Golf Clap…..

    Still laughing about the “musical pimps” comment. Maybe the funniest description of the band that I’ve ever heard. Can’t wait to use that one while describing them to my non-phish friends.

    Friend: “Who is this band that you go see all the time”?

    Me: “Seriously man? These guys are the musical pimps of the universe! HOW have you not heard of them? You’ve probably never worn a snuggie either have you?”

  10. Guyute711 Says:

    I just read your post axillalot. I am glad someone else heard the War Pigs tease, I was going crazy at the show!

  11. HarryHood Says:


    How you holding up bud?

  12. Type III Jamming Personality Disorder Says:

    let me try this again…

    2009 is a year of Phish I never thought would happen. I had resigned myself to the fact that a huge part of my musical life was complete and that I would never again get to experience the unbridled communal joy and auditory bliss inherent to Phish shows. I had even gotten to the point where I seldom listened to Phish anymore because it somewhat painfully reminded me that I would never reach that level of congregation again. I had moved on, much like one does after the end of something big in their life, looking for something to fill the huge hole left behind. But then 2009 happened.

    I now stand at the bass* of the cliff side with both feet firmly planted ready to leap at whatever Phish brings us in 2010. I know that in the past I took this band for granted and when it was over I wasn’t ready for the crevasse left behind. 2009 was a great year for reconnecting with the band I love and rediscovering the community of wonderfully kind people drawn to it.

    Thank you, Phish, for reminding me why music is more than just something to listen to and allowing me to rediscover something I assumed was gone forever for me. Thank you, Miner, for providing the platform where all of us like-minded phreaks could discuss this obsession in our lives and open up connections with people we had never met but felt like we’d known our whole lives. And thank you, Blackboarders, for being what you are and communicating with each other so well about all of the varied things that make this board the great thing that it is.

    Phish ON!
    The next show is the best show!
    Long live the musical pimps of the universe!

    *intentional. Mike, to me, stood out as the new found star of this band throughout 2009. His consistent performance and prowess in leading the way into and out of jams opened up my eyes again to the oneness of being phish.

  13. BeantownBoy Says:

    This is your friendly reminder that TAB pre-sale begins in 20 minutes.

    I’m not expecting a huge demand, but then again, who knows.

    Who’s in? And if so, where?

    As for me, here I come Beantown HOB!

  14. nonoyolker Says:

    @ Beantown – I have my calendar reminder up. Not quite the thrill of Phish ticket day, but it’ll at least get the blood flowing this A.M. Hitting the HOB as well

  15. Guyute711 Says:

    Marshall, I was 12th row lower level on Page side pretty much right at the front corner of the stage. I saw what happened after the song. They switched behind the drum kit right before she came out and took a bow so that really was Sarah taking the bow. It was a little to confusing at the beginning so I didn’t see the initial switch but realized that it was Fishman pretty quickly.

  16. jay Says:

    anybody else having trouble with the Mega upload link? I get the page with the captcha but no ads and the submit button does not work.

  17. Litteringand Says:

    Going to Atlanta for work today anybody got suggestions for good local places to eat. (love me some BBQ)

  18. EL Duderino Says:

    Tabernacle here BeantownBoy

  19. Litteringand Says:

    @Type III couldn’t have said it better myself

  20. BeantownBoy Says:


    Nice, if there are enough folks from the board going we should try to arrange a mini-meetup before the show. Maybe Boston Beer Works?

  21. nonoyolker Says:

    @ Type III – nicely put…

  22. EL Duderino Says:

    anyone know what the ticket limit per show is? Been looking all morning and can’t find any info

  23. nonoyolker Says:

    @ Beantown – In. I think there are a handful of us massholes lurking about

  24. Panda Says:

    Shine a light on 2010!!!!!!!!!!!!

  25. Type III Jamming Personality Disorder Says:

    if I can figure out how to scrape together the money for TAB tix, I’ll definitely be there. I’d like to hit both Boston and Wallingford but if I can only do one it’ll be Boston.

Leave a Reply