Readers Picks: Josh Finkenberg

12-28-12 (Graham Lucas)

12-28-12, MSG (Graham Lucas)

All selections and text by Josh Finkenberg (@JoshFink17)

“One and Done”

March is my favorite time of year. The Vernal Equinox. Hope springs eternal. Phish drops tour dates. Tour plans are put in motion. Emails with phriends putting said plans in-motion. Sun-dresses and halter-tops. Pools open in Vegas (alas no Phish again this year). Dog beach. Spring training. NCAA March Madness. Filling out your brackets (be it your basketball picks or favorite Phish jams of 3.0 or all-time), upsets possible almost in every game, excitement of the buzzer beaters, split screens, watching David (Bowies) go up against (dried up) Goliaths (and a weasel names Fee) and the win or go home nature of the tournament. One and done—a fate that has befallen many tournament teams and over 300 Phish songs‚— is the theme of my Readers Picks… songs that Phish has only played once.


Mr. Completely7.15.03 II, Salt Lake City, Utah (Anastasio)

I love jams—strawberry, grape, Lebron during warm-ups, and of course Phish. This is the greatest one and done jam Phish has ever played. Storming the court, this nearly 45 minute deep and winding jam moves in and out of “Low Rider,” “BBFCFM,” “Buried Alive” and “Ha Ha Ha.” One of the best 2.0 jams period, and yet played only once by Phish.



Garden Party12.31.12 I, New York, NY (Ricky Nelson)


Garden Party

Speaking of basketball, a moment of silence for the Big (Ball Jam) East who after this season will look dramatically different. MSG has hosted the Big East Conference tournament since 1983, the same year Phish was formed. Coincidence? I think not.  MSG has seen some awesome basketball and some awesome Phish. Unlike almost every other song on this list, I don’t think Phish should ever play “Garden Party” again. This NYE opening number was the perfect song at the perfect time in the perfect place in Phishtory. I don’t need to say much about this one because Mr. Miner already had a perfect take on this moment.



Terrapin Station”8.9.98 E, Virginia Beach, VA (Garcia/Hunter)

The roar from the crowd after Laettner’s last second shot vs UConn has nothing on the roar from the crowd as it processes what is about to go down on 8/9/98. I get goose bumps every time I hear that roar. Played as the encore on the anniversary of Jerry’s death, I have been at every Phish show on August 9th since and have selected “Terrapin Station” as my bust-out in our setlist game every time. I am 0 for 3 from behind the arc.



The Rover 6.24.10 I, Camden, NJ (Led Zeppelin)

Physical Graffitti

Physical Graffitti

You know the drill: Phish announces a Halloween show (the selection committee announces the brackets), phans start guessing what album will serve as the musical costume (fans start filling out their brackets) and a lot of people are convinced that this is Zeppelin’s (Louisville’s) year. Phish seems to be aware of this as displayed in the 10/30/10 “Ha Ha Ha! Were Not Costuming Zeppelin Show.” While it will never be “No Quarter ” (a perfect Phish cover) I would love to hear Phish try “The Rover” again and produce a better version than this one. Amazing stat: Phish has played “The Rover” live in concert more times than Led Zeppelin did.



Spanish Moon” 10.31.10 II, Atlantic City, NJ (Little Feat)

Little Feat - Waiting For Columbus

Waiting For Columbus

Speaking of musical costumes, the last Halloween costume Phish donned was Little Feat’s Waiting For ColumbusWaiting for Columbus is one of my favorite albums, so it was pretty special to see Phish absolutely nail it. It has been very surprising to me that for whatever reason Phish has yet to take a song from this Halloween show and turn it into a regular staple of their own a la “Drowned,” “Crosseyed and Painless,” and “Rock N Roll.” Trey indicates that this is one of their favorite songs and they crush this version like UNLV crushed Duke in 1990. Getting down at this show, I felt confident “Spanish Moon” was going to be added to the Phish cover repertoire. Alas, it’s been a Spanish New Moon (despite the “Skin it Back” head fake.)



Them Changes” 11.30.97 E, Worcester, MA  (Buddy Miles)

Everyone (including this guy) wants Phish to bust-out “Izabella” again. Buddy Miles was Jimi’s drummer in Band of Gypsys—I would love to see another Jimi influenced song taken off the shelf.  Unlike “The Rover” cover, Page absolutely crushes the vocals on this one. Trey has a great solo and some shredding work throughout. The band is locked in with some speed rock in the end. Incredible cover…please skin it back.



Layla” 11.29.98 I, Worcester, MA (Eric Clapton) 

Layla and Other Asst. Love Songs

Layla and Other Asst. Love Songs

Eric Clapton is a prolific singer-song writer, musician and performer. Thus it is quite surprising that Phish has covered one of his songs. This song features a very successful sit-in by Seth Yacovone from Burlington (whose bands first gig ever was at Nectar’s.) This is a great version—it’s fun to watch Trey and Seth rock back and forth just as you would imagine Clapton and Duane Allman doing back in the day followed by the Chairman of the (back)Boards flawlessly playing the piano coda written by Jim Gordon. While I doubt we will see the Phish from Vermont play “Layla” again due to its guitar and singing complexities, this was truly a special moment; The Kevin Durant of Phish one and dones.



Pigtail12.28.10 I, Worcester, MA (Anastasio/Marshall)

The third one and done from Worcester on my list. Fortunately Marcus Camby was not a one and done for UMass (also in Worcester) and led them to the Final Four in 1996. This song made its debut with Phish at the DCU Center but since then has only been seen with TAB (including six times in 2013 alone.) Although Trey’s voice is a bit shot in Phish’s version, I really like this catchy tune and think it would make a nice addition to live Phish.



Rhymes06.07.11, Mansfield, MA (Al Green)

This song had been seen in a decent number of Cactus shows prior to making its debut in the first set in Mansfield. At the time we had no idea about the song but were really digging the groove and loved Gordon’s lyrical enthusiasm. “Rhymes” has some serious potential if Phish chooses to take it out for a spin again.



Time11.2.98 II, West Valley UT (Pink Floyd)

Dark Side of the Moon

Dark Side of the Moon

They play this version straight ahead, albeit with the help of the CD being piped into the sound system for the clocks and alarms sounds in the beginning of the song. If only I could go travel back in “time” and go to this show. That magical night in Utah is the only “time” Phish has covered Pink Floyd (excluding “Bike” and a dozen or so versions of “The Great Gig in the Sky.”) It’s “time” for Phish to bring other Pink Floyd songs back into the mix. Phish has been playing for 30 years; I have been seeing them for 20. “Time” keeps on slippin’, slippin’, slippin’ into the future (another one and done.) It’s a minute in “time” that we exist, we slowly make our way into the mist (not one and done.) We don’t know how many more “times” we will have the opportunity to see Phish and see shows with our loved ones. Enjoy life – it’s a great “time” of year.

[audio:] Tags: ,

811 Responses to “Readers Picks: Josh Finkenberg”

  1. Mr. Palmer Says:

    That Gillian Welsh cover at Dicks two years ago was pretty nice.

    Good list. Way to change the theme up a bit.

  2. harryhood Says:

    @ mia

    Do I need an invite? Its saying its a private group….

  3. harryhood Says:

    My user I’d is boirec and my email is

  4. MiA Says:

    Harry, give it a shot now. Just sent an invite.

    Maybe be too late though… 11 AM Eastern might have been the last time to get your picks in.

  5. tela'smuff Says:

    good call Palmer, i liked that one as well.

  6. plord Says:

    @Selector – Nope, born and raised a sheltered suburban nerdy Virginia boy, fled for the bay area after college– I’m sure I’ll tell that story again sometime– came back east a few years ago but settled in a more philosophically hospitable region.

  7. Dorn76 Says:

    If guests count then I vote for Everyday I have the Blues and Thrill is Gone.

    The way Trey says, “today…tomorrow!” definitely adds to RL’s interpretation. Ready to think about Phish and an album, just hasn’t started to yet.

    One guy on Morning Joe, Jon Heilman, was clearly a phan or knows something about it. Asked 3 questions, all about Phish. Amanda Greene just sat there and smiled that toothy smile.

  8. MiA Says:

    We have:

    Dr. P
    Heady Bro
    Sel J

  9. Phamily Berzerker Says:

    is there a buy in for the BB bracket

    Too late? oh well

  10. Selector J Says:

    Definitely agree with both “Thunder Road” and Welch’s “The Way It Goes” (I had to look it up.) Such a dark tune, Welch’s. I remember really digging it from couch tour and initially thinking it was a new Mike original.

    “Best song he’s ever written! Wait, it’s not… oh, nevermind. Still… great song. Kudos for the sweet cover, guys.”

    @plord – VA represent! MiA and I have VA roots, too. I was born and raised in Williamsburg. (Yep. Williamsburg… AMA I’m a tricorn hat expert.)

  11. Dorn76 Says:

    As for 3.0, taking out guests and Halloween, Night Nurse has to be in there for being a kick ass tune they played well.

    And Big Balls. Hilarious.

  12. harryhood Says:


    Thanks man. I’m in!

  13. roberto luongo Says:

    disagree MIA

    in every interview I’ve heard he has talked about how this broadway project has just been such an enjoyment but also a huge drain on his time and creative energy.

    not sure how not having a massive project that you are attempting for the first time cannot diminish the output of your other projects

    doesn’t even make sense

  14. roberto luongo Says:

    I have not felt in all-in Trey in 3.0 except for Dick’s 2011-2012

    I feel this weight and risk off his shoulders could def see a bit more fire under his ass this summer

    seems logical to me

  15. Mr. Palmer Says:

    Got my bracket in.

    2012 Phish was great. Didn’t affect Troy last year…

  16. makisupa Says:

    thanks for the remind, BB (MiA) on the bracket

    love this format, Miner. Well done submitters

    Night Nurse is the goods, from 2010’s best show (got to pick one, right Utica and AC?)

    summer tour: gotta go Gorge, tempted by CHI and Bangor – Toronto

    SF, tahoe, denver will be epic.

  17. makisupa Says:

    sign in on cbs sports

    more trey hilites from coffee talk this AM?

  18. roberto luongo Says:

    Trey also has a short attention span so finishing this project could cause him to move on from the recent pop/rock more mainstream style songwriting he was applying when writing HOAHB

    just my .02c

    hoping for a bit less sterility and more insanity this summer

  19. tela'smuff Says:

    I’m definitely getting the sense from this recent press tour that while the broadway stuff has been a dream come true, it was way more work than he anticipated. i agree, it’s gotta have some kind of affect on him and the band. which bodes very well for this summer. seems Phish could be getting his full attention.

  20. Dorn76 Says:

    He also talked about when on stage someone takes a wrong step and they have to start the take over….the unforgiving nature and precision required for that.

    Time to get loose big guy!

  21. MiA Says:

    You’re probably right RL. 2012 Dicks was purely what we mostly have been waiting for IMHO.

  22. kayatosh Says:

    nice list of one and done’s (there have been many great ones), finkenberg.

    agree w/ the other posters who said that night nurse, monkey man, and you ain’t going nowhere need to be on that list.

    two more to add: Flip (Glide II) (5.16.95) , On My Knees (7.17.99)

    gambler was fairly badass as well.

    Rover was the bomb. Thrilled to have caught that one.

  23. Kaveh Says:

    Game on! Good luck to all the BB Bracket submissions.

  24. kayatosh Says:

    nice list of one and done’s (there have been many great ones), finkenberg.

    Rover was the bomb. Thrilled to have caught that one. and major kudos for Them Changes and Terrapin

    agree w/ the other posters who said that night nurse, monkey man, and you ain’t going nowhere need to be on that list.

    two more to add: Flip (Glide II) (5.16.95) , On My Knees (7.17.99)

    Gambler was fairly badass as well.

  25. kayatosh Says:

    and i liked Rocket Man, as well. Page is phish’s secret weapon for cover tunes.

Leave a Reply