The Baker’s Dozen

The Baker’s Dozen (Andrea Nusinov)

Well, well, well… The band that has continued to outdo itself throughout their thirty-four year career did it once again with—unquestionably—the greatest event they have ever thrown. The Baker’s Dozen wasn’t just a run of shows, it was a summation of Phish’s entire career and a statement of where they stand today. Their residency at Madison Square Garden showcased the band’s endless musical catalog, unparalleled improvisational prowess, carefully contoured set crafting and cleverness of mind—the four central elements that define Phish. Meticulously planned and perfectly executed, the Baker’s Dozen will be talked about, listened to and remembered by the Phish community for the rest of time.

Jim Pollock

In the months leading up to the Dozen, perhaps the most popular topic of debate among fans centered on whether the band would repeat any songs during the course of the run. With thirteen shows spanning two and a half weeks, the band would essentially have to play an entire tour—Fall ’16 spanned exactly 13 shows—without repeating a song. Could they do it? Sure. Would they do it? That was an entirely different question.

Conventional wisdom said that if they chose to go the “no repeats” route, they would be forced to play long improvisational passages, thereby cutting down the number of songs per show, a stepping stone towards their goal. They would have to feature more than just a smattering of covers to supplement their original music, something they had done throughout their career. Fans debated back and forth, but in the end there was only one answer, as the band in question was Phish. Of course they wouldn’t repeat a song. This feat was likely impossible for any other band in history, but for a band that has made a living for three decades by breaking musical precedents, there was no other choice. 237 songs in thirteen nights, and not a single note repeated. Only Phish. Only Phish.

Baker’s Dozen (Andrea Nusinov)

Not since the late 90s, and dare I say not since their hallowed Fall ’97 tour, has Phish brought all facets of their superior game night after night after night, delivering sculpted musical journeys that will go down in the annals of their illustrious history. But unlike their legendary tour of Fall ’97, when Phish destroyed America, the mind-quests of the Baker’s Dozen were not birthed from a single musical paradigm, but from styles spanning their entire career, and sprinkled with some new sounds as well. In the yesteryears of Phish’s first Golden Age, the band honed in on a musical focus each tour and they fleshed out their ideas through that unique prism while often moving beyond those styles. But the brilliant sets of MSG featured improvisational escapades of all shapes, sizes and colors, forming a sonic smorgasbord that spanned the totality of the band’s musical spectrum. From the ambient sounds of “Wolfman’s > Twist > Waves” to the laid-back candy grooves of “Mike’s Song” and “You Sexy Thing;” from the soaring, bliss-drenched jams of “Chalk Dust” and “Ghost” to the murky abstractions of “Drowned > A Song I Heard the Ocean Sing;” from the knee-deep funk of “Everything’s Right” and “46 Days” to the psych-jazz of “Taste,” Phish showcased their diverse musical genius with utmost flair for thirteen straight nights.

Even more than their lights-out jamming, however, Phish’s set crafting stood out as the defining element of this run. The thirteen second sets were each thought out sagas with unparalleled flow—fantasy-like Phish. These seamless musical adventures wrapped one so intimately in their narrative arcs that it often surprised the listener when the final page turned—“Whoa—what just happened?!” And this wasn’t just the case on few of the nights, but nearly every evening of the run. Second sets contained nimble contours that guided the collective and delivered it to the Promised Land. Even during some of their most prolific tours, the band often did not consistently present coherent musical statements as they did at the Baker’s Dozen. And unlike previous tours, when certain shows and jams stood out amongst the rest, the Baker’s Dozen provided a counter-example—the entire thirteen nights was the highlight. Each night stood alone in its excellence, offering a flavor of its own. Every night was the best. We had ascended to Phish heaven.

Baker’s Dozen (Andrea Nusinov)

On top of the to-die-for music, the band threw a heap of classic Phishiness into the Baker’s Dozen with nightly, pre-announced donut themes, creating a community-wide mystery each day and making sleuths of every fan as they tried to figure out what the band would play to match the flavor of the night. Referencing themes with new covers, puns, lyrics and song titles, the band was in peak prankster form crafting these detailed affairs, clearly enjoying the process. The clever nature of the Baker’s Dozen added the proverbial cherry on top of the most unique and original extravaganza of Phish’s career.

And then it came down to the run’s twenty-sixth and final set. Within, ironically, the one show without a strong musical connection to its theme—this stanza unfolded like a poem that encapsulated the ethos of Phish’s career.

“We’ve got it simple ‘cause we’ve got a band.”

Behind the spectacle that is a Phish show—behind the lights, the crowds, the jams, the energy, the madness, and the beauty—there is a band, four lifetime friends who have had the ride of their lives making music with each other. Though the ride hasn’t always been easy, the choice has always been simple—this musical project is what these guys were put on this planet to do—to play together in a rock and roll band. The joy they derive from playing in Phish is self-evident, and play they did in one of the defining jams of the Baker’s Dozen.

“I’m a part of you, and you’re a part of me”

Baker’s Dozen (A.Nusinov)

This cosmically significant lyric from “Come Together,” when taken in reference to the Phish community, depicts how integral the band and its fan base are to one another, illustrating how the two forces have come together and risen up to form one of the most fabled communities in rock and roll history. Phish has never been shy about their symbiotic relationship with their notoriously passionate fans; it is, self-admittedly, what has driven this whole experiment from their humble Northeast beginnings. The exchange of energy between the band and its loyal followers at their live shows creates a unique, communal catharsis that none of the participants—on either side—find anywhere else in life. Forays into the unknown result in moments that transcend our individual nature and blossom in the one energy of which we are all comprised. Illusory boundaries of the self are shattered in explosions of metaphysical truth, and no one is never the same again. These ego-dismantling experiences allow all involved to tap into the one consciousness, the one soul of which we are all made, and revel in the divinity of existence.

“There’s a starman waiting in the sky / He’d like to come and meet us / But he thinks he’d blow our minds”

Baker’s Dozen (Andrea Nusinov)

“Starman” holds a important significance in story of The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust. After he is contacted in a dream, Ziggy becomes the rock and roll messenger of an infinite Starman, who will descend from space to save humanity from it’s imminent demise. Ziggy spreads this messianic message of hope and love through his music, prompting people to follow him and believe in Ziggy, himself, as a prophet. The parallels between the story of Ziggy and Phish are striking. Phish has come into existence in this time and in this earthly dimension to invoke a musical and spiritual ecstasy within a western American society that has lost touch with the cosmic truths that exist within each and every person. Phish are messengers of the beyond, our Ziggy Stardust through whom the infinite is manifested.

A Phish show transcends music and enjoyment, giving fans a glimpse of reality beyond words and beyond the mind, something eternal. Peak live experiences remind participants that there is more to existence than what is routinely perceived. And I don’t think there is one person in the band’s massive fan base that wouldn’t claim that Phish and their music has saved them at least once in their life. Phish provides us inspiration and vitality, belief and spirituality, which we carry with us into our lives beyond the dance floor. Like modern day shamans, Phish has been our spirit guides through this crazy world, and has brought to us peace, community, and unconditional love. And beyond all of that, Phish—for three hours at a time and for decades on end—has “let all the children boogie,” providing fans an outlet to let go of life’s difficulties, and to bask in nothing but the timeless moment. In their own way, Phish has saved the universe.

You Enjoy Myself

7.23.17 (Andrea Nusinov)

Culminating this final set came Phish’s seminal composition-turned-throw down, “You Enjoy Myself.” Not only is this piece one of the most well-loved selections in the band’s musical cannon, but its silly and oft-dismissed title holds a significance in this set. “You Enjoy Myself”—you (the fans) enjoy myself (Trey, the composer / Phish, the musicians). This title is a selfless statement of Phish’s mission—they bear their souls for our enjoyment, or put from their perspective, “Our intent is all for your delight.” Sure, Phish has been the band members’ path to well-being and success, but their ultimate purpose is so much bigger than that. Trey has said it over the years many times in many ways, but perhaps most directly in “Joy“—We want you to be happy.” It’s plain and simple. To say they have succeeded in their goal would be a colossal understatement.

“What a beautiful buzz”

For all involved, band and fans alike, what a beautiful buzz the Phish experience is—the most beautiful buzz on planet earth. And with “Loving Cup,” this poignant, message-laced set of music concluded in an explosion of arena-wide exaltation.

“The life I love is making music with my friends”

With the encore, the epilogue of a seventeen-day odyssey, Phish brought this set-long statement full circle, back to the simplicity of music and friendship with the heartwarming cover of Willie Nelson’s “On the Road Again.” Its lyrics and meaning in the context of a career-defining residency need no interpretation.

On the road again
Just can’t wait to get on the road again
The life I love is making music with my friends
And I can’t wait to get on the road again

On the road again
Like a band of gypsies we go down the highway
We’re the best of friends
Insisting that the world keep turning our way
And our way, is on the road again

“Won’t you step into the freezer.”

And what other way to finish the Baker’s Dozen—after one last sprinkle of clever humor in a “Lawn Boy Reprise”—than with “Tweezer Reprise.” Phish’s go-to shot of musical adrenaline and rapture punctuated a signature run of shows that will go down in band—and music—history. We have all stepped into the freezer and found a home in the universe Phish has created. It is the most majestic, invigorating, and life-affirming universe we have ever known. It is a universe of truth, and it is most definitely a donut.

Baker’s Dozen (Andrea Nusinov)

Baker’s Dozen (Andrea Nusinov)

Baker’s Dozen (Andrea Nusinov)

Baker’s Dozen (Andrea Nusinov)

3,687 Responses to “The Baker’s Dozen”

  1. HeadyBrosevelt Says:

    LU- Maple is one of my favorite nights. That 46 Days is my shit, yo; I swear Page is teasing to the Romantics during that jam, “I hear the secrets that you keep, when your talking in your sleep.”

  2. HeadyBrosevelt Says:

    11.13.1997 is so good. Definitely listening to the whole tour over the next month.

  3. Phamily Berzerker Says:

    Caught the first 4 of Fall ’97.

    Big loop road trip from ATX>PHX>LV>SLC>DEN>ATX

    I told the story some time ago. good times!

    Do not speed in Utah. 😉

  4. Random Poster...Nutbag Says:

    I fully endorse speeding past cops in Fort Collins post show in Heady’s bus with Pham B at the helm. Simply fantastic.

  5. Type III Jamming Personality Disorder Says:

    11.14 is a fantastic day for phish shows

  6. Doc pro Says:

    Man I must’ve been tired on Maple night. It was my least favorite of the run that I caught. Felt like golden age never really gelled, like they were kinda gassed and didn’t have the same kind of either peak or dark/weirdness ideas. I thought it was the least successful of their 20+ min set openers. Then when they landed in Leaves there was an audible groan and deflation in the room. The Swept>Steep was amazing and felt like an apology for Leaves. Then 46 days too felt disconnected leading to the marimba section, and then they closed strong from there thru possum.

    Probably projecting from my headspace to theirs. I’ll give it another full set spin, and will focus more on what Fish is doing. Also probably suffered from being sandwiched between two of my favs – jimmies and holes.

    Glad to see some dissection of the BD now that the dust has cleared a little. I still am listening to it pretty exclusively, though I’ve started the Fall 97 listen back.

  7. Leo Weaver Says:

    Good to see this place is still open! Hope you guys are all doing well, no complaints here.

    I’ve landed on the Stash’teca show for my TIPH listening. ’95, man…whoa.

  8. little umbrellas Says:

    Holes set 1 is a good time. Fun song selection. WAN heavythings maybe the first kinda moment where i’d take a step back from total engagement and puff and take it all in.

    Way Down In A Hole, buried alive, kdf, guyute, nicu, meat maze, ginseng, antelope . Keeps a phish party rockin.

  9. little umbrellas Says:

    Dr Pro, I don’t think you’re sentiments there towards the Maple show are totally unique. For one , hard to pair up those shows against Jam filled and Powdered.. I had considered Boston Cream, Maple, and Holes as the ‘least exciting 3’ of the whole run.

    But taking in each show on a phresh head has been super revealing of all the gems and treats in each show. Golden Age might not fully stand up next to the Drowned Ocean .. But in it’s own way is a fantastic flowing jam.

    Each show really had an awesome contour.

  10. little umbrellas Says:

    Bostom Cream Petrisnore might be the only ‘whaaaa’ i walk away with from my listen back.

  11. wilbard Says:

    ^ spun Holes the other day LU and I thought the same thing. Set 2 is obvious but that first set is really tight and fun too

  12. little umbrellas Says:

    ^excited to spin that Mike’s tonight
    , if i remember correctly, was the first time the 2nd jam happened in the proper way (key/transition) since its return. (Where you can tell the band actually listened to what they used to do and executed it)

  13. Doc pro Says:

    Oh yeah, lil um, any other year and that would’ve been a tour highlight. Just shows how amazing a run the BD was. I’m still discovering little gems and fresh ideas everywhere in there

  14. Doc pro Says:

    That holes 2nd set was so so amazing. First the 2nd jam, then oh holy night which was so funny and psychedelic and just perfect, and then the head scratcher of Taste slowly morphing into a run highlight of its own. Just an epic 40 min of pure phishiness

  15. little umbrellas Says:


    Also this : POLYGONDWANALAND . King Gizz so crazy. Yet another album !

  16. Type III Jamming Personality Disorder Says:

    leo knows

    and btw I have your winnings from the League. Just waiting on a couple of deadbeats to pay up

  17. halcyon Says:

    Hi BB.

    MSG is 46 Days away.

    “Taste the fear
    For the devil’s drawing near”

  18. halcyon Says:


    Did you ever get my email and $. Hit you up a couple of months ago. This deadbeat shouldn’t be dead anymore.

  19. Type III Jamming Personality Disorder Says:

    not you, halcy. you’re good. sorry, should have confirmed with ya!

  20. halcyon Says:

    Sounds good T3. Figured life, kids, work, etc got in the way with a confirmation

  21. MrCompletely Says:

    LOL Gizzard promised 5 albums this year? I missed that. This will be number 4 so they’re on it

  22. little umbrellas Says:

    ^right C? .. !

    They put out a video for the first song on it. ‘Crumbling Castles’.
    Closer to Nonagon but a blend of some of their psych stuff and not quite as Motorhead/Devo.

    The video is rad tho. All analog from hardware VJ equipment . Looks dope. 10 minute jammer.

  23. Jerome Garcia Says:

    Who’s spun the new BBlade & TFB? teeny b? MrC? If so thoughts?

  24. MrCompletely Says:

    absolutely, JG. my thoughts? brian blade is the shit as usual, and I like the Fellowship Band a little more than that other project with the piano player. basically his excellence is so sustained that it’s all just variations on the same super high level

  25. vapebraham Says:

    Sally Holes (8.2.17) — $$$. plexy, fab funk.

Leave a Reply