Chucktown Throwdown

12.29.09 (Wendy Rogell)

On a Saturday night in North Charleston, Phish dropped their finest two-set effort of this young tour, blowing out each frame with fresh jams colored with unparalleled musicianship and communication by all four members. Juxtaposed to their endless setlists of Friday, the band crafted a show that flowed like liquid from start to finish, and almost felt like we saw two second sets worth of music. Throwing down the gauntlet from moment one, this show had IT from the get go, never moving through a single lull on the way to churning out a venue full of beaming fans. Just before a two-day break prior to entering their home turf of New England, Phish has raised the bar for the rest of tour with a show that simply never stopped.

Official Charleston Poster

Opening with an appetizer of “Kill Devil Falls” and “Guelah Papyrus” – both played for the first time this fall – the set got rolling in earnest with the only “Curtain (With)” of 2010. Boasting a gorgeous “With” jam this sparked a set of serious music as the tour debuts continued with an energetic “Mango Song” and a filthy “Sand.” When the band kicked into “Sand” midway through the first set, they delivered a message loud and clear – this night would be special. Shredding apart a dynamic groove Trey set the tone for his own playing for the evening – a night he annihilated from start to finish in, arguably, his best outing of fall thus far. “Sand” provided the first outright showcase for his chops, and he took liberty in leading the band through a version to be reckoned with. Flowing with lead melodies over a outstanding and changing groove, this version possessed far more passion, direction and urgency than any of this era (with Camden ’09 being the only counterargument) as the whole band interplay transcended the norm for the song. Fishman altered his beats, Mike molded diverse bass lines and the entire band shifted through connected segments of jamming in an indelible psychedelic excursion. Musical Density x Phish crack = really enjoyable times. (Or MD x PhC = $$$)

12.30.09 (W.Rogell)

Trey’s infectious playing spilled right into “Limb By Limb” where his solo took added life, and into slammin’ “Sneakin Sally” that went without any real exploration in a first set go-round. In his only the southern stop and while having a particularly hot night, Trey pulled out the intricate Bill Monroe cover “Uncle Pen” to the delight of the Saturday night South Carolina crowd, and proceeded to lead the band through a rousing rendition. The dark-horse jam of the set came in from another 2010 premiere – “Pebbles and Marbles.” Bursting at the seams with energy, Fishman guided the jam with a hard, driving beat, urging Trey and Mike into uncharacteristically fast playing that resulted in some absolutely sublime moments. This version sprinted its way into the first set highlight reel with daring improv and blistering whole band communication that juiced more from the song than usual. Upon dropping a perfectly placed “Cavern,” Phish was ostensibly closing a smoking first set, but when the song ended, the band didn’t leave stage, and after a brief moment, revved up a bonus “David Bowie” that punctuated the opening frame far more dramatically.

But as hot as the opening half was Phish came out for set two and promptly dropped a musical statement that is among their best of the year – no bones about it. Boasting a non-stop flow and jams aplenty, the band blazed a fiery trail of music that never relented. Blindsiding everyone with “Crosseyed and Painless,” Phish came out with a multi-tiered exploration of the Talking Head’s cover. Cranking through a fiery initial expedition, Trey once again took front and center with his warp-speed soloing as the band crushed a liner, yet scorching jaunt through Crosseyed’s melodic themes. When the band pulled back into the lyrics, however, they weren’t close to done. Oozing into a space-aged ambient experiment, Trey painted eerie singular notes over a drone landscape, pushing the piece far into avant-garde abstraction. Thinking this segment would develop into the next song, Phish instead refrained “Still Waiting” once again and proceeded to move into a third section of jamming. Growing into a mid-tempo groove with a slick melodic tone, it seemed like the band wasn’t stopping. But the jam came to an natural end as they resolved the section fairly quickly to a massive ovation.

12.4.09 (Graham Lucas)

“Dirt” provided an introspective moment before Phish leapt into a mid-set “Fluffhead.” But unlike the many  modern-era versions that break up flow of the second set, this one worked perfectly as the band crushed a nearly note-perfect rendition of their collegiate composition. Building a full head of steam through the five-part piece, Phish exploded at “The Arrival,” imploding the Coliseum with a colossal peak. But when “Fluff” came to a close, the best sequence of the show was ready to unfold.

Dropping immediately into the ambient built of  “2001,” Phish wasted little time getting to business in a scorching version that is rivaled only by (but, in my opinion, smokes) Camden’s Michael Jackson-laced escapade for tops of the era. Whereas the band has generally played generic versions all over 2009 and 2010, this one contained additional octane, activity and interplay that set it far apart. Torching the building with a relentless mid-set dance session, Trey teased the opening lick of the first theme multiple times during the furious funk before taking the song to into its intial peak. And after surfing a rhythmic tsunami to its subsequent one, the band slipped into the my personal highlight of the night – a ginormous second set “Tweezer.”

10.12.10 (S. Short)

Taking a divergent path than versions we’ve heard of late, Phish infused this “Tweezer” with belligerent creativity, creating an original mind-melter that left no jaw unhung. If you’re like me and get off on thick, raunchy Phish grooves, get your headphones and let this one rip, because you are in for a delectable treat! After a composed section that the band filled with all sorts of accents and enhancements, Trey came out of the gates in his raw, uncompressed, post-hiatus tone, throwing a surprising twist into things right off the bat. Getting downright menacing and swampy, the band’s rhythms complimented his ideas like a cosmic brontosaurus. Trey switched into out of his dissonant voice and began weaving strands of gold before before Fishman anchored a smooth change into a sparser groove – a move coaxed Page and Mike into prominent lead roles in this dense virtuosic journey. Dripping with crunching, forward-looking grooves, the band threw down the type of stuff that I dream about – a different monster than any 2010 incarnation and perhaps one of most indelible ten minute segments of music we’ll hear all tour. Layered with new ideas and uber-dynamic interplay between all four members – just get this one on as soon as possible!

8.15.10 (M.Stein)

As the “Tweezer” bust through its denouement, Trey wound up “Show of Life,” combining the two songs for the first time. Using the fall debut of his new song tactfully as a late-set bridge, the emotional anthem fit like a glove between “Tweezer” and the set’s closing “You Enjoy Myself.” Many had buzzed about the “Brickhouse YEM” from ’95 in the same building, and when the band dropped into the song’s opening arpeggios, one couldn’t help wonder the band was giving a subtle nod to the epic half-hour version. But one way or another, “YEM” – unplayed since Austin – was due up to close the show in style. And with an extremely laid-back rendition, Phish did exactly that, putting an exclamation point on a night of stellar jamming. A nuanced, whole-band conversation shied from any guitar heroics and brought all four members into collective focus in a series of swanky grooves.

As Phish set down their instruments, they knew as well as we did what just went down. They all sported shit-eating grins and stayed onstage longer than usual to soak in the raucous approval. And when they returned they capped the evening with a triple encore of “I’ve Been Around,” “Quinn the Eskimo,” and “Tweezer Reprise,” finishing off the show like they started it – on fire. With the first leg of tour now behind us, Phish prepares for the Northeast and beyond with a top-notch show under their belts and ready to drop a whole lot more.

I: Kill Devil Falls, Guelah Papyrus, The Curtain (With), The Mango Song, Sand, Limb By Limb, Sneakin’ Sally Through the Alley, Uncle Pen, Pebbles and Marbles, Cavern, David Bowie

II: Crosseyed and Painless > Dirt, Fluffhead, Also Sprach Zarathustra > Tweezer > Show of Life, You Enjoy Myself

E: I Been Around, Quinn the Eskimo, Tweezer Reprise

Tags: ,

1,120 Responses to “Chucktown Throwdown”

  1. sumodie Says:

    some great ph discuss tonight, cool. Even better we’ll have more fresh ph tomorrow, er…tonight technically

  2. DukeOfLizards Says:


    You’ve still got 60 seconds to be right the first time.

  3. Monsterpus Says:

    Purple Humpback Whale-So sorry you didn’t get in. That’s BS! It was good to meet you though

  4. lot rat Says:

    pumped for amherst….cant wait to hit the plane friday night and get off in the new england fall sat morning…(Hope its not 40 and raining).

    both umass and manch….diggin it

  5. Robear Says:

    A friend talked to K. Shapiro last night at the Waterwheel showing of Coral Sky video, and he said that Trey said SC 2 was the best they have played since the return.

    does that ‘friend’ post on the Greenboard?

  6. RamblinOnMyMind Says:

    @Sumo – just wanted to thank you again for getting me in touch with that girl looking for Manchester tickets. Looks like it all worked out, barring any mail mishaps.

  7. Robear Says:

    miner, out of curiosity:

    do you think the band played significantly better for both sets of SC 2 than say, both sets of Brim 2 or 3? Or do you like the song choice and flow better? Or both?

  8. BTB Says:

    Finally made it through SET I & II. What an enjoyable 2 sets of music.

    big smile

  9. sumodie Says:

    @Rmblin: cool -hope the deal closes

    I’ve still 1 Manchester & 2 Sunday UMass extras

    But Augusta & Utica await

  10. sumodie Says:

    @Robear: SC2 bristles with band energy thru n thru -I’d say this show

    However, I’d take a wacky well played Brim3 show any day too

    Ocedoc sounds amazing all over the place -Trey’s just beginning to unleash that beast

  11. wow Says:

    wow. I am not veteran… 45-50 shows, maybe less (I should count that), moreover my first one was 2003 MSG reunion so I missed the glory; with Trey playing like his – hell, with everyone playing like they are – im hoping that a new day of glory is in conception. IT WAS THE BEST SHOW I HAVE EVER SEEN <— SOBER NIGHT 2 LOL

    Im in Augusta, can't sleep because thats how I felt the night before Saturday (night 2) in SC so im trying to get superstitious to ensure it continues; Im praying it does and im thinking it will. Stay up yall!!!

  12. Whole Tour! Says:

    @ robear – yes, SC2 was THAT good! I wasn’t expecting them to surpass the level of playing that they reached this summer (especially in the south), but they did. One of the most solid nights of phish i have ever witnessed. It was more of a “group mind” playing than anything up to this point in 3.0.

    and it holds up nicely on tape. it was outstanding.

    And even after re-listening to SC1 today for the first time – it too was a great show. The argument that a long song length/long jam = a good song is no longer relevant. The energy and execution is what they are striving for in this era and that is what nigth one was all about. Night 2 was more of a classic group mind phish show – 3.0 style. it was out of this world and i’m not just fluffing it because i was there.

    I have read somewhere that people felt that the “Sand” from SC2 could have been longer. could have been smould of been. What they did with that song in that amount of time was incredible.

  13. thedayman Says:

    im diggin the tweezer>show of life combo, pretty solid, specially with a fatty yem afta, i mean thats just absurd. this second set is insane

  14. purplehumpbackwhale Says:

    @monsterpus – thanks. next time you’re walking dogs in stuytown and you need a bane/phish break let me know.

  15. garretc Says:

    Damn, around 8:00 in SC Sand, Mike throws down THE sickest bass solo. Trey just hears him coming up and drops out for a little while and Mike slays it

  16. Mr.Miner Says:

    do you think the band played significantly better for both sets of SC 2 than say, both sets of Brim 2 or 3? Or do you like the song choice and flow better? Or both?

    ^ yes played better. and better flow to both sets..Trey ripping harder in SC than CO

  17. Josephish Says:

    first east coast and indoor show for me. drove 6 hours to pick up some buddies at southern illinois then hit the road for a crazy 12 hour drive. I picked up my friend and he took me to his buddies house and we jumped in the car popped a pill kinda like adiral or better put baby ecstasy. i was able to drive the whole way there in about 12 in a half hours couple of stops and alot of cigarrettes. Saw the whole drive Smokey mtns and all. made it there two oclock in the afternoon or one oclock SC time. joint on the beach only 30 min outta the way and hit the lot till show time.

  18. Phish in the Lou Says:

    What up everybody, long time reader first time poster. Mr. Miner, so cool to see you are a LOST fan. You and I have 2 very similar loves.

    Just DL’d SC2 can’t wait to listen.

  19. Jeff Says:

    I have been to many (100+) phish shows in my 20 years and this show may be the best show I have wever seen or heard. Ever.
    I just listened to it again and it still sounds special to me.
    It makes me cry to listen to it.
    It’s just powerful. A sonic tidal wave that swept over Charleston for a night and left it more beautiful the next day.

  20. simvastatin Says:

    Very good write-up. I certainly loe this website. Keepp it up!

    Feel free to surf to my bllog post: simvastatin

Leave a Reply