December ’95: Vintage Phish

December ’95.  The mere mention of this special page from calenders past conjures up so many feelings drawn from that freezing cold month of blazing hot Phish.  Many still argue that this was the pinnacle of the band’s career- it doesn’t get any better. Though hard to compare the Phish “up to 1995” and the Phish of “1997 and beyond,” and reluctant to rank eras- it could be suggested that December 1995 was the peak of everything the band had done up to that point in their career.  Polished, and raging like never before, their musical styles that had been explored and developed over the course of over a decade, were coming to a unified head at the end of 1995, concluding with their biggest show ever- their first ever New Year’s Eve extravaganza at The Garden.

11.14.95 Orlando / photo:

The context of December ’95 must be put into perspective to be truly understood.  It was the culmination of a tour that began at the end of September.  Only taking one week off after Halloween, Phish had toured for two and a half straight months-54 shows- their last tour of such magnitude.  With the New Years’ Run, these December ’95 shows culminated 58 shows over the fall and 82 shows over the year.  To put it in even better perspective- December ’95 was the culmination of 204 shows over a torrid 1994 and 1995. That averages out to practically one show every three days for two years!  With all of the extensive experimentation and exploration that went on over the course of this time, it was as if Phish was heading into the final month of 1995 bringing to the table the best of what they had discovered.  Incredibly refined and gleaming, Phish moved into the final two weeks of their fall odyssey chugging tighter than ever.  They say practice makes perfect, and if everything prior was practice- December 1995 was perfect.

One day after a great show at Dayton’s Nutter Center, December 1st saw Phish at Hershey, PA. for an epic show that has since been released on  The northeast-centric month brought them up through New England, all over upstate New York, with additional stops in Cleveland, Portland, Providence, and Philadelphia.  Each show was fire, showcasing the mind-boggling communication, risk-taking, energy, and precision that had come to define the band’s decade plus history.  Practically every show in the month is famous for one reason or another, all leading up to two nights at the Olympic Center in the small town of Lake Placid- the incredibly intimate mini-arena where the US Hockey team upset the Soviets so many years ago.

During the month, the band was literally firing on all cylinders every single night, producing some of their most hallowed music during the last bend of fall tour and their famously epic New Years Run.  Their musical adventures were jaw dropping, producing insanely high-paced psychedelia on a nightly basis.  Yet, it was a cultivated psychedelia- the music was absolutely crazy while tightly harnessed and controlled by the band with seemingly no effort.  Every show was better than the next; a display of musical gymnastics night after maddening night.  You could feel the collective wave of energy surging each in every arena, building to the frenzied heights of Madison Square Garden on the 31st.  Through twelve years of grass roots determination, incessant touring and the melting of so many minds, Phish had reached rock and roll’s mecca on its holiest night of the year- and we all know what happened next.  They imploded rock’s biggest arena with their consensus “best show ever.”  What else would you expect from the Phish?

Beyond its insane shows and sublime music- December ’95 represented the mountaintop.  Phish had succeeded.  Using their own quirky self-driven model, songs that just didn’t make sense to so many people, and a unique unmatchable style, Phish had reached the summit.  At this point in their career, they could have chilled, producing years more of their patented frenetic journeys that people had grown to love.  They could have continued doing what had finally proven successful.  But they didn’t- they wouldn’t be Phish if they did.  Fueled by the need to continue pushing the envelope- although it took almost a year to figure out their next musical direction- by the time 1997 rolled around Phish had transformed into something bigger than before, and people were running for cover.

December 1995 was the end of an era.  It was the end of Phish scrapping and clawing to make it.  They had now officially made it.  The month represented a vessel masterfully being sailed to shore after years atop the stormy seas, by four salty dogs that had seen it all.  Phish would no longer to need to navigate the industry; they would begin to call their own shots.  They would begin to have more of a hand in designing their tours and their soon-to-be legendary festival weekends.  Phish would get much bigger in years to come; more institutionalized with the Dead no longer around.  More people would come to shows- as Phish was the preeminent counter-culture band, and scene, in America.  The band responded to these array of changes around them with change of their own.  Into a crunchy groove monster they would grow, cruising the outer realms of the galaxy for the late ’90s.  But this is not about the late ’90s, this is about December 1995, a very special time in the hearts of all who were there-and in the ears of those who weren’t.  This was Phish at its best- take it or leave it.  It seems like we all took it- hook, line, and sinker.

To bring us back through the epic month on December 1995, I have put together “Miner’s Picks: December ’95” This compilation features ONE selection from each show of the month, in order, from Hershey to MSG.  Take a trip down memory late or learn some history you didn’t know before.  It was hard to pick only one selection from each show but I did, and I present to you the links and track listing below: (with a bonus disc of must haves!)






1,2. Mike’s > Weekapaug: 12.1 Hershey, PA.

3. Tweezer: 12.2 New Haven, CT

4. Run Like and Antelope: 12.4 Amherst, MA

5. Bathtub Gin: 12.5 Amherst, MA

6. Split Open and Melt: 12.7 Niagara Falls, NY

7,8,9,10. 2001 > Tweezer > Kung >Tweezer: 12.8 Cleveland, OH

11. YEM: 12.9 Albany, NY

12,13. The Curtain > David Bowie: 12.11 Portland, ME

14. Down With Disease 12.12 Providence, RI

15. Split Open and Melt 12.14 Binghamton, NY

16,17. 2001 > David Bowie 12.15 Philadelphia, PA

18. Reba: 12.16 Lake Placid, NY

19,20,21. Free > 2001 > Harry Hood: 12.17 Lake Placid, NY

22. Tweezer: 12.28 Worcester, MA

23,24,25. Bathtub Gin > The Real Me > Bathtub Gin: 12.29 Worcester, MA

26. Harry Hood: 12.30 MSG

27. Reba: 12.31 MSG


28. Mike’s Song 12.31 MSG

29. Harry Hood 12.05 Amherst, MA

30. Drowned 12.31 MSG

31. Tweezer > Tweezer Reprise 12.17 Lake Placid, NY

Tags: ,

11 Responses to “December ’95: Vintage Phish”

  1. Phish — All Those Years Ago… « Musical Stew Daily Says:

    […] with their biggest show ever- their first ever New Year’s Eve extravaganza at The Garden. Continue Reading… Posted by Musical Stew Daily Filed in DOWNLOADS, Phish Tagged: […]

  2. Schroeder Says:

    Thank you!

  3. Greg Says:

    I tried downloading your ’95 Oicks and it said it Download is Unavailable.

  4. Jacob Says:

    Thank you Mr. Miner. Yeah, the 12.14.95 Split is a regular in my iPod rotation. I really think it showcases the power of Mike and Fish, and the creativity of Trey and Page, all working together.

  5. Matso Says:

    Delighted to see that the 12/17 Tweez/Tweez Reprise made it onto the bonus disc (and in such esteemed company). In the flesh, this jam didn’t make sense to me at the time, but it became a fav on tape. I love the way it breaks down to just Page and the way Trey builds the tension again before launching into the Reprise.

    Another sweet post. I feel drunk on all this Phish.

  6. Matso Says:

    I’ve been working my way through these Picks and have to say, December 1995 still deserves its awesome reputation. I just can’t get over how much fire in there is in the playing. Most of these versions are played at what feels like breakneck speed – see 12/9 YEM, for example – I had this version on tape and I sometimes wondered if the recording was too fast but I doubt it was now when you listen to other stuff from the same month side by side. (On a related note, listening to the Albany 97 Yamar in your Cover’s Picks, I wonder if this recording was a bit slow – Mike’s voice sounds very low).

    Miner, I know you’ve made a good case to rehabilitate Summer 99’s reputation, and while I agree that there were some good moments and some really fun shows, it doesn’t even come close to something like Dec 95 (or Fall 95 as a whole, really). I love late 97/early 98 too and some 03/04 jams are as good as anything the band ever did, but if there was one month, or even one week of shows I wish I could relive, it must be from this month.

    Besides the quality and inventiveness of so many of the jams from this month, I just also really love the band’s sound from this tour. Fish had switched to a new kit for the fall tour and was using a much heavier snare drum, which gives a lot of the jams a more bombastic feel (see the various Free’s, Tweezers for example). Page’s piano also rings out much more, especially in the lower registers (does any know when he started playing the grand with the top closed? I wonder if this might have anything to do with it). Page was also working the clav and moog into the jams more (this started in fall 94/summer 95 with the clav, but in those fairly abstract settings). Finally, Trey was still using the older ‘doc at this point, so his tone had so much body to it, and although he was using some effects (see various Mikes, Weekapaug’s) it was not to the extent that the tone was completely lost (as I feel it would later start to be in 97). Only complaint really would be that the PLM hadn’t formed yet and Mike is a bit low in the mix.

    Anyway, thanks again for making all this available – much appreciated!!

  7. craig Says:

    I was at that Hershey show 13 years ago…there were about 5,000 people there. I went back in 1996 for the Hershey Stadium show and there was about 20,000 peeps. I’m really glad I got to see them during that time in their career.

  8. EJ Says:

    Thanks for the compilation, Mr. Miner. I would have to include on this list Mike’s–>Groove from 12.7. The segue is just so freakin’ smooth. But it goes to your point of it being hard to narrow down the highlights of these tremendous shows.

  9. Nick Says:

    for some reason I can’yt load .rar files. I’m trying to get a copy of 12-15-98, which was my 1st show. Any way to get a bit torrent download or is megaplaud the only one available?

  10. casey Says:

    I’m happy you included the Melt from 12.14. For me personally that was my peak Phish experience. At the end of Melt they play into a silent jam but on the tapes you can hear the crowd keeping the time. They then slowly bring it back. I have never seen such band/crowd participation before and it was unbelievable…

  11. Jason Says:

    I was fortunate to see the Albany 12/9 show. The snow storm was rough and I went alone not knowing anyone else who wanted to go. I don’t remember the show that well to be honest except enjoying it. Years later I realized how monumental seeing them in December ’95 and that Albany YEM was. I’ve always been a pre ’97 fan and even though the band had more incredible tours ahead of them, the combination of musicianship, creativity and excitement was never better than the ’91-’96 era imo.

Leave a Reply